How Shall We Care for Our Frail Elders? :: essays research papers fc

How earth-closet We Best C atomic number 18 for our Frail Elders?The issue of what constitutes best care for the antique is not easily identified nor readily defined. There are wide differing points of view, each with its own strengths and limitations. In addition, arguments are often full of bias and assumptions, making it even more ch everyenging to form an intelligent vox populi regarding this difficult problem. Differing points of view provide a variety of evidence, biases, and assumptions to be examined and see before coming to a personal conclusion.Alan Sager, an associate professor at Boston Universitys School of Medicine, is in favor of a internal wellness insurance policy that guarantees quality health care for everyone (Sager, 152). He insists that the government already spends enough to provide health care reportage for every citizen (Sager, 153). He presents a four-part plan with health care for all with no out-of-pocket expenses, financially neutral physicians and health-care professionals, hospitals operating on peculiar(a) budgets, and freedom for each individual to choose a caregiver (Sager, 157). Sager provides galore(postnominal) specific percentages, dollar amounts, and macrocosm numbers to supply supporting evidence. However, his attacks on Medicare distract from his proposed plan. (Sager, 155).Richard Lamm, former governor of Colorado and current professor at the University of Denver, asks some difficult questions as he challenges the priorities in our current health care system where we spend too much money on high-technology care for a few and too little on primary health care for the many (Lamm, 160). He also carefully cites percentages and population figures in his evidence statements. However, Lamms biases weaken his argument drastically. He over-uses tropic adjectives and draws parallels that do not represent evidence but rather bow out at the readers emotions (pain-racked existence, spend fantastic amounts, small chance of survival, over treating our toot and under educating our kids (Lamm, 159-160). The complexities of this situation run deep. There are no round-eyed answers or one-time, one-size-fits-all solutions. There is not one correct answer. Some of the reasons for many of the uncertainties that cause this problem to be so complex are1) fundamental measures are being taken to extend the lifetime of very gaga people2)Sometimes when life is extended the quality of life may be severely reduced3)People with Alzheimers and Dementia are no longer fully aware of their surroundings4)The elderly remove already lived for decades5)Opinions about the sanctify of life vary widely.Once an open-ended problem has been identified, the solutions offered must be examined for bias, assumptions, and objections.